NYC Therapy for Highly Sensitive People (HSP)
Do you often feel overwhelmed by noise, bright lights, emotions, or the fast pace of city life? If you're a Highly Sensitive Person (HSP), navigating New York City can be uniquely challenging. At Madison Square Psychotherapy, we specialize in therapy tailored for HSPs—offering compassionate, personalized support to help you find calm, clarity, and confidence in the midst of chaos.
Feeling everything all the time can be exhausting. If you're a highly sensitive person (HSP), the fast pace and constant stimulation of a place like New York City might leave you overwhelmed, emotionally drained, or like you’re always on edge. Therapy can help you make sense of your sensitivity - not as a mental health disorder to "fix," but as a part of who you are that can be better navigated. At Madison Square Psychotherapy, our therapists offer highly sensitive person therapy that provides compassionate, personalized support to help you regulate your nervous system, improve low self-esteem, set better boundaries, and feel more grounded in your day-to-day life.
If you’re looking for support coping with high sensitivity, we invite you to book a free consultation call with one of our therapists. In a mainstream culture that often misunderstands what the "big deal" is when it comes to HSPs emotions, it's essential that you find the specialized support you need. This no-pressure call is a chance to ask questions, share what you're looking for, and see if we’re a good fit. Sensitivity is a strength—and you don’t have to navigate it alone.
Meet our HSP therapists
Madeleine Phelan, LMSW
Madeleine Phelan is a compassionate psychotherapist specializing in supporting highly sensitive clients (HSPs). With a deep understanding of the unique challenges highly sensitive individuals face, she provides a safe and empathetic space for clients to explore their emotions and experiences.
Madeleine integrates trauma-informed approaches, mindfulness, and somatic awareness to help HSPs navigate overwhelm, build resilience, and embrace their sensitivity as a strength. Her collaborative and client-centered approach empowers individuals to cultivate self-compassion, engage in self reflection, and thrive in a world that often feels overstimulating.
Credentials: Licensed Master Social Worker (LMSW)
Clientele: Highly Sensitive People (HSPs), young professionals, individuals navigating life transitions, anxiety, trauma, and relationship challenges
Location: 303 5th Avenue, Suite 1303, New York, NY 10001
Virtual therapy?: Yes
Kristin Anderson is a compassionate psychotherapist specializing in supporting individuals navigating life transitions, relationship challenges, and emotional distress.
With a holistic approach that recognizes each person's unique experiences, she integrates Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Psychodynamic Theory, and Mindfulness-Based Interventions to empower therapy clients in their journey toward higher self-esteem and growth. Her empathetic nature and unwavering attention to detail create a safe space for clients to explore their emotions and develop practical tools for self care while navigating life's complexities.
Credentials: Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW)
Clientele: Women's issues, relationship issues, anxiety, depression, and trauma
Location: 303 5th Avenue, Suite 1303, New York, NY 10001
Virtual therapy?: Yes
FAQs about counseling for highly sensitive people
-
Highly Sensitive People (HSPs) tend to feel emotions deeply, experience sensory overload (meaning they become easily overwhelmed by sensory input like loud noises or chaotic environments), and need more time to process stimuli than others. They may find that they have stronger reactions to stimuli or situations than others and that they even need more alone time in order to feel refreshed. They may wish they had a higher capacity for normal environmental stimuli. HSPs may also have certain personality traits - including the trait of high sensitivity to subtle details - that can leave them feeling emotionally exhausted from normal life.
You might be highly empathetic, easily overstimulated, or sensitive to criticism, while also feeling like you have a constant inner critic. Maybe you can't watch certain movies or tv shows because they are too intense or you find yourself feeling too deeply moved for your emotional sensitivity. Or you may find yourself experiencing increased sensitivity to even subtle cues or physical sensations. If any of this sounds familiar—or even if you’re unsure—feel free to reach out. Therapy can help clarify your experiences and support your emotional well-being.
-
Therapy can help HSPs manage overwhelm, process emotions more effectively, and develop personalized strategies for navigating a stimulating world. Highly sensitive people tend to benefit from learning boundaries, understanding HSP traits, and developing self-compassion, and tools for emotional regulation. Many HSPs also struggle with social anxiety and feeling flawed - both things that therapy for HSP can greatly improve. A skilled therapist and the therapeutic process as a whole can offer validation, reduce anxiety, and support your unique needs in a safe, understanding space.
-
For HSPs, or anyone with a sensory processing disorder, its extremely important to find a therapist who has not only a greater understanding of the traits that many HSPs possess, but also a deep knowledge of the common challenges that they face. Our approach is rooted in compassion, attunement, and respect for your high sensitivity and emotional world. At Madison Square Psychotherapy, we offer a calm, nonjudgmental safe space where your sensitivity is honored—not pathologized. We work collaboratively, using mindfulness, trauma-informed care, and evidence-based therapies that are paced to soothe increased brain activation and suit your nervous system. Our mission is to help you uncover your true self and thrive without needing to “toughen up” or become someone you’re not.
-
We’ve found that modalities like Internal Family Systems (IFS), Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), and somatic-based approaches work particularly well for HSPs. These therapies center emotional safety, coping strategies, self awareness, and self-acceptance. Our clinicians integrate these methods with mindfulness and somatic awareness to help you feel grounded, empowered, and in control of your sensitivity.
-
No, being a Highly Sensitive Person is not officially classified as a form of neurodivergence, but rather a sensory processing sensitivity. HSP is considered a normal, genetically-based temperament trait, often linked to biological sensitivity, found in about 15–20% of the population. However, HSPs often experience the world differently, picking up on non verbal cues and some may relate to aspects of neurodivergence due to their sensory and emotional intensity.
-
Sometimes, yes—high sensitivity can develop as a trauma response, especially when someone grows up in a chaotic or invalidating environment. But for many, HSP is an innate trait, not a result of trauma. At Madison Square Psychotherapy, we help you explore your story, understand the origins of your high sensitivity, and heal any wounds that may contribute to intense emotions or overwhelming situations.
Get matched with one of our NYC therapists today
Feeling deeply and being emotionally responsive is part of who you are—and therapy can help you navigate that with more clarity. If you're curious about working with us, we invite you to book a free 15-minute consultation call. It's a simple, supportive way to connect with a therapist and see if our approach feels right for you.
Ready to get started?